'Sound Identification of Terrestrial Mammals of Britain & Ireland'
By Neil Middleton
Stuart Newson
Huma Pearce
With photography by Sandra Graham
The following, is my "Cliff notes version", of the back cover of the book:
A volume covering 42 species of terrestrial mammal. From the red deer to the pygmy shrew, from the pine marten to the hedgehog. Treated as a single field of study... This volume covers survey methods, the analysis of sound recordings, as well as software. The book includes species in Britain, Ireland, the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands.
This book contains almost 300 figures in total, each species covered in detail, along with specific spectrogram examples.
In addition, this book allows the reader to access a (downloadable) sound library, with more than 250 recordings. I won’t go into too much detail about it here, but I will say that I found it to be a very valuable resource.
The authors have extensive experience and expertise in bioacoustics, as well as in the sound identification of mammals.
They are also heavily involved in creating tools that use machine learning algorithms to identify mammal species from their calls (quite fascinating).
The image on the front cover of the book, is of a Red Deer stag (Cervus elaphus) calling (by Philippe Clement)
The book was published November 14th 2023. It is 392 pages in length, with 328 figures, 16 colour photos, 43 maps, and 98 tables.
It weighs 1150 grams.
It arrived promptly (to me in New York) and well packaged.
Physically, it’s a beautiful hardcover book; featuring high quality paper. You’ll see what I mean when you get your copy…
It’s also available on The NHBS site:
Chapter 1 – Introduction & Context
This first chapter helps to lay out what the scope of the book is. As well as:
The differences between audible and ultrasonic sound, examples of the estimated populations of both small and large terrestrial mammals in the British Isles, some of the things surveyors can expect to encounter, classifications/the various orders of mammals in Britain and Ireland, and what influenced the authors decisions in choosing what would be covered in the book.
It may seem a bit vague, but what struck me about this chapter, is simply how very well laid out and well written it was.
Chapter 2 – Survey Equipment & Field Techniques
One of my favorite chapters in the book, it deals with The technology employed when performing mammal surveys. As always, I’m very keen on discussions of various kit. This chapter provides the reader with an introduction to: Gathering, and interpreting acoustic data; it includes a very useful chart organizing terrestrial mammals by which are (predominantly) audible, or ultrasonic. It covers: an overview of frequency and amplitude in relation to distance, external influences on the distance at which sound may be heard or recorded, recording quality, signal-to-noise ratio, and survey equipment.
Also, some very useful info regarding: how to make the most of video recordings, as well as a valuable chart on estimated distance in meters, for the recording of animals in the family Muridae. In this case: various mice, voles, shrews, and rats. The authors touched on the most helpful information regarding microphones and their use, and related equipment.
Chapter 3 - Analysis of Acoustic Recordings
Topics covered include: The various software applications currently available, ultrasonic sound, frequency/time, sound analysis (obviously), sound versus noise, attenuation, measurements, as well as filters and classifiers.
There is also a table depicting sound component shapes encountered during call analysis – this will be a valuable resource for ecologists!
Chapter 4 - The authors provide an overview, of the six chapters which follow (chapters five through 10).
Chapter 5 – Even-toed Ungulates / dear species and wild boar
Chapter 6 – Carnivores / Wildcat, fox, badger, otter, stoked, as well as other mysteries
Chapter 7 – Lagomorphs / Rabbit and hare species
Chapter 8 – Rodents (large) / squirrel species, and beaver
Chapter 9 – Rodents (small) / rat, mouse, vole, and dormouse species
Chapter 10 – Insectivores / hedgehog, mole, and shrew species
Personally, I thoroughly enjoyed this chapter; since I’m very interested in moles and shrews. Unfortunately, hedgehogs are not native to the United States.
These six chapters did not disappoint! They were each filled with invaluable, modern-day resources on exactly what to expect, when targeting these various species for recording and sound analysis.
Each chapter included:
- Wonderful tables, which could be understood at a glance.
- Screenshots of spectrograms created in Batsound software.
- QR codes relating to each species covered - they take you to the recorded sound files, and they work a treat!*
- Invaluable bits of information*
* I’m being intentionally vague here, so as not to give away too much!
This book contains such relevant and useful information on the species it covers – It would make a wonderful field guide. Unfortunately, I find it to be far too lovely of a book to think about taking into the field. So perhaps it would be better to refer to it, after a day or evening of recording in the field?
Appendix I - provides a neat glossary, which would be particularly useful to beginners in this field; as well as naturalists/hobbyists just starting out.
Appendix II - Provides data on fascinating case studies. Specifically, Dormice, Water Voles, Rats, and Shrews.
Things I liked:
- The fact that we wildlife sound recordists (both Pro & non-Pro) now have a handy reference for recording mammal sounds.
- The book is well laid out, well written, and full of invaluable resources.
- I like the way key points of interest, and useful data, are accessible at a glance.
- It's very thorough, sharing all the information I would want, regarding each species it covers.
Things I didn't like:
- I would have liked to see the technical/equipment details on which microphone & recorder was used, for many of the recordings. I say many of the recordings, because to have the gear details for all of the recordings wouldn't be practical.
First and foremost - This truly is a groundbreaking, and innovative book; being the first to tackle the splendid subject of: Recording the sounds of terrestrial mammals. It is for all intents and purposes the first, and only of its kind.
It may only cover (specific species of) Britain and Ireland...However, as many of us are aware:
- Some of the species surveyed are located in other parts of the world.
- Most of the species recorded have similar (comparable) species, in other areas of the globe; ensuring that it will be useful to many.
There isn't much not to like about this book - It's certainly akin to a one-stop encyclopedia on recording terrestrial mammal sounds.
In summary, if you work with terrestrial mammals – and most especially if it is in the British Isles or Ireland: then you simply must get a copy of this book!
Another interesting point, is that this book will be a very welcomed addition on the shelves of both professionals and hobbyists/naturalists. The excellent writing style, featured throughout - is both super-useful for an Ecologist; while being advantageous and easy to understand for a determined beginner. I say determined beginner, because it may be too technical for a complete novice.
I can't say it won't spark an interest in recording terrestrial mammals...
Note that Chapters 1 through 4 will definitely appeal to a large audience of readers. Nevertheless, right around the area of Chapter 5 and beyond, is where the book gets serious - Some might say more specifically technical.
All things considered, I can still affirm that the only prerequisite, is having an interest in the sounds which terrestrial mammals make.
I'm confident in stating that folks such as myself, and the readers of this blog, will simply cherish this book. If you record the sounds of mammals, either as your vocation or avocation - It warrants looking into!
I hope to add some additional bits of information, reflections, thoughts and marginalia to this review going forward.
Until next time,
Happy bat detecting! Mammal recording!
P.S. My apologies for the delay in posting this review. It should've been completed a bit sooner. This time, the entire blame goes to my Fibromyalgia (and chronic pain). I had far too many days of consecutive pain, to have accomplished this review in a timely manner.
